Logo
Contact Newsagent Login
Scoop Search
Articles & Opinions Cook Is Fiji FSM Hawaii Kiribati Marshall Is Nauru New Caledonia Niue NZ
Papua New Guinea Samoa Solomon Is Tahiti Timor Leste Tokelau Tonga Tuvalu Vanuatu West Papua

Australian policy on Fiji ‘dysfunctional’, says report

17:30 November 30, 2011Fiji, Frontpage, Opinions, Pacific Headlines3 comments

Fiji's military leader and Prime Minister, Voreqe (Frank) Bainimarama. Photo: Selwyn Manning

Pacific Scoop:
Commentary – By Graham Davis

The folly of Australian policy towards Fiji is at the centre of a damning new landmark report that suggests the United States has lost confidence in Canberra’s ability to influence events in the Pacific and counter rising Chinese influence in the region.

It calls for the immediate and unconditional lifting of regional sanctions against Fiji and for Australia to “repair its relationship at the highest level” by re-engaging with the Bainimarama regime through the Pacific Islands Forum.

“It is well past the time to treat this festering regional wound,” it declares.

The report – covering all aspects of Australia’s relations with the Pacific and entitled “Our Near Abroad” – has been issued by the Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI), an independent, government-funded think tank set up in 2001 to advise Canberra on its defence and strategic policy options.

Direct challenge
The conclusions of its authors – Professor Richard Herr and Anthony Bergin – are bound to stick in the craw of Australia’s foreign minister, Kevin Rudd, for they present a direct challenge to the entire edifice of current Pacific policy.

The report details in stark terms the extent to which Australia has been isolated in the region and is losing its ability to influence “collective decision making in the South Pacific”.

It cites as evidence the fact that eleven Pacific Island members of the United Nations have formed a voting bloc that excludes Australia and that the Melanesian Spearhead Group (MSG) – which also excludes Australia – has backed fellow member Fiji against Australian sanctions.

It calls on Australia to “regather the threads of regional leadership” with a comprehensive range of measures that include repairing its relationship with Fiji, a country it describes as being at “the heart of the Pacific Islands regional system” as the principal transportation, communications and diplomatic hub.

“The region cannot survive without its heart” – the report says – describing Fiji’s suspension from the Pacific Islands Forum as having “seriously changed regional dynamics”.

ASPI warns of the consequences of Fiji seeking new international relationships because of its breach with Australia and New Zealand over Frank Bainimarama’s 2006 coup.

China ‘significant beneficiary’
It says Fiji’s membership of the Non Aligned Movement  “underscores Suva’s more aggressive pursuit of South-South dialogue, specifically to reduce reliance on its traditional friends, including Australia.

“Whether intended or not, China has been a significant beneficiary of this development as a leading state in the NAM”, the report concludes.

The authors suggest that Fiji has outwitted Australia to the detriment of its national interests in the Pacific and the strength and cohesion of regional organisations such as the Pacific Forum .

“The importance of Fiji for the new geopolitics of the region is that it’s actively challenging Australia’s privileged position in the regional system. There are many reasons why Australia should repair relations with Fiji, but the deleterious effects of the current contretemps on the Pacific Islands Forum are the key because they cascade through the regional system”.

The report cites  “the impossibility” of concluding the current PACER Plus trade negotiations and “the rift between the Pacific Islands Forum and the Melanesian Spearhead Group”, which have taken opposing views on Fiji.

Sanctions ‘impractical’
It goes on to say that “Forum-related sanctions (against Fiji) are being subverted by other organisations, including the Secretariat of the Pacific Community (SPC),  the Forum Fisheries Agency and even RAMSI,  the billion dollar Australian intervention in Solomon Islands.

It describes those sanctions as “impractical” and says “they have proved dysfunctional for Australia and for its image in the region”.

It also says the delay in repairing the relationship has been costly, partly because attitudes in Fiji about the need for Australian assistance appear to have hardened”.

As well as the lifting of sanctions, the report calls on Australia to follow New Zealand’s lead in re-establishing ministerial contact. More controversially, it also calls for the re-establishment of Australia’s ties with the Fiji military to deal with maritime security, border protection and transnational crime.

ASPI goes on to examine the divergence in approach between the United States and Australia towards Fiji, exemplified last week when Washington’s new ambassador in Suva, Frankie Reed, visited Frank Bainimarama in the prime minister’s office.

No Australian or New Zealand head of mission has had any direct contact with the Fijian leader since his coup five years ago.

The report quotes Reed as having described Fiji’s position in the Pacific as “unique” and said it was “a key focal point in America’s larger regional engagement with the South Pacific”.

US ‘more direct’
In stark contrast with the Australian position, the ambassador said the US sought a “more direct engagement with Fiji’s government to encourage the restoration of democracy” within the regime’s stated timetable of September 2014.

The ASPI report says that while “the US is reluctant to openly express criticism of Australia’s handling of regional relations, it’s clear there are genuine doubts about Australia’s capacity to lead islands’ opinion on relations with China”.

It concludes that “the US is taking on a more direct role in protecting its own interests in the region, just as it did in the mid to late 1980s when it felt that managing Cold War challenges in the Pacific Islands was beyond the capacity of Australia and New Zealand”.

Graham Davis is an investigative journalist and media commentator. His articles are frequently published by Pacific Scoop. He publishes the blog Grubsheet where this commentary was originally published.

  • Print This Post Print This Post

3 comments:

  1. Ulli Weissbach, 1. December 2011, 10:41

    How many think tanks do Australia and NZ need to re-discover the need for re-engaging with Fiji. First the Lowy Institute, which demonstrated with its recent poll in Fiji, that this dictatorship might not be as evil and unpopular as we are told. And now ASPI talking about American discomfort about Australia and NZ’s total surrender policy towards Fiji. This policy is unprofessional and – in terms of foreign policy – undiplomatic. You don’t get anything with ultimatums but you may gain something if you keep talking. The fact that Fiji appears to be serious to hold elections in 2014 – by introducing an electronic voting system and other measures – only strengthens the need to re-engage with Fiji. We need Fiji as a trading partner, a transport hub, a regional ally and – last but not least – as a holiday destination.

     
  2. truthseek, 4. December 2011, 20:39

    The fallacy that has been revealed is the fact that, the Trans-Tasman bullies and to an extension the ANZUS alliance have historically used these think-tanks which have been the recipients of funding by several front organizations.

    The report underscores the flawed reality that, most regional Governments who subscribe to these advice; have under-estimated the stupidity of these think-tanks and the academics and re-cycled politicians/ civil servants within it, who actively flaunt their specialized expertise in South-Pacific geo-strategic, geopolitical affairs in the mainstream media. Final result- group think with endless feed back loops.

     
  3. Coralia, 12. December 2011, 16:08

    I totally agree with the 1st comment. The Aus & NZ government are achieving nothing with their hard line stance & a change of approach in how they deal with Fiji is so important. It doesn’t take a genius to figure that out – let alone 2 separate major think tanks.

    All they have got to do is to accept the fact that their original approach on Fiji is not working – change course and get started on the road to effective engagement. Or is losing a bit of face on the diplomatic front more important?

     

 

Search Pacific.scoop.co.nz

Pacific Media Centre newsfeed

  • WEST PAPUA: Facebook still censors photo – ‘nudity’ or politics?
  • SOLOMON IS: Watchdog role of media highlighted in USP journalism talk
  • FIJI: Islands Business director blasts police detention as 'intimidation'
  • REGION: USP 'epoppers' raise Pacific climate awareness with cellphones
  • REGION: Want to lead in the Pacific? Try listening first




  • Pacific Links

    • About Pacific.Scoop
    • AUT's new Pacific journalism course
    • Brown Pages
    • Knowledge Basket Pacific
    • Pacific Cooperation Foundation
    • Pacific Journalism Review
    • Pacific Media Centre – AUT University
    • Pacific Media Watch
    • Pacific Scoop Internship
    • Pasifika Foundation
    • University of the South Pacific
  • Pacific Media

    • Asia-Pacific (Al-Jazeera)
    • BBC’s Asia-Pacific
    • Cook Islands News
    • Fiji Daily Post
    • Fiji Sun
    • Fiji Times
    • Fijilive
    • Hawaiian Independent
    • Islands Business
    • Kiribati Independent
    • La Dépêche de Tahiti
    • Les Nouvelles Calédoniennes
    • Matangi Tonga
    • Māori Television
    • New Dawn FM 95.3
    • NewsWire (Whitireia)
    • Niu FM
    • Oceania Flash
    • Pacific Islands Report
    • Pacific Mini Games newspaper
    • Pacnews
    • PasiMA
    • PIMA
    • PINA
    • PMC on YouTube
    • PNG Post-Courier
    • Radio Australia’s Pacific Beat
    • Radio Djiido
    • Radio Fiji
    • Radio NZ International
    • Radio Rakambia
    • Radio Tarana
    • Radio Waatea
    • Reportage (UTS)
    • Reportage-Enviro
    • Samoa News
    • Samoa Observer
    • Samoalive Newsline
    • Solomon Star
    • Solomon Times
    • Spasifik magazine
    • Sunday Chronicle (PNG)
    • Tagata Pasifika
    • Tahiti Presse
    • Tahiti-Pacifique
    • Te Waha Nui (AUT)
    • The National (PNG)
    • TNews (NZ)
    • Vanuatu Daily Post
    • Xtra media
  • Pasifika Blogs

    • Avaiki Nius
    • Coup Four And A Half
    • Croz Walsh’s Fiji
    • David Robie’s Cafe Pacific
    • Global Voices Online
    • Grubsheet (Graham Davis)
    • Malum Nalu’s PNG
    • Nga Reo Tangata
    • Pacific Eyewitness
    • Pacific Freedom Forum
    • Pacific Media Centre Niusblog
    • Tempo Semanal
    • Whenua Fenua Enua Vanua
  • REGION-WIDE NEWS:

    Pac Scoop VideoPacific Media Centre: YouTube channel's latest videos

    Rainbow Warrior’s ‘last voyage’ to Rongelap left lasting legacy

    Alistar Kata reports for AUT’s Pacific Media Watch project.

    AUT student journalists report Rainbow Warrior special bulletin

    AUT University television and journalism students contribute to special Eyes of Fire microsite.

    • Pacific Headlines

      • Fresh groundwater potential discovered in Cook Islands
      • Pacific Social and Environmental Responsibility Policy
      • Pacific maritime leaders see community based approach as key
      • Salvation shows the value of float-free EPIRBs
      • Disasters could cost Asia-Pacific region $160 billion a year
      • Vaccines are protecting more children, but millions miss out
      • Tabuteau attends Pacific Economic Ministers Meeting
      • ANZAC Day “Patriarchal Bollocks” work temporarily installed
      • Former All Blacks join rugby legends for Golden Oldies
      • Visitor numbers still flying high
      • APEC, Business Pursue Bold Trade Actions for Changing Times
      • Measles Alert for Kuala Lumpur flight passengers
      • Ngā Taonga Sound & Vision brings Moana with Sound to Aucklan
      • Royal Academy of Arts on ‘Oceania’ exhibition
      • Bridging the gap in the world of cocoa


    MEET THE PMC TEAM

    Introducing some of the faces and projects involved in AUT's Pacific Media Centre. Meet Josephine Latu from Pacific Media Watch, Violet Cho from Irrawaddy magazine, filmmaker Jim Marbrook and TVNZ Tagata Pasifika's John Utanga, director David Robie and others. About Pacific Scoop. – PMC

    Toktok - Feedback

    • Sickputer: "...contamination also flows f...
    • Linda Ballou: I am happy to see the cloak an...
    • PS: So. the US fleet will be fishi...
    • Alofa Tautogia: I think in the future wen stoc...
    • John Monro: I can't be anything like as en...
    • Andrew Johnson: There is no lack of trust, the...
    • Bo Lagerqvit: According to the Royal Swedish...
    • Putra Pihakunu: Thank you. God bless you all f...
    • Will Ilolahia: VakaWhenua disaster houses are...
    • George: There is a very widespread per...

    Categories

    • American Samoa
    • Asia-Pacific Journalism
    • Australia
    • Columns
    • Cook Is
    • Fiji
      • Fiji Elections 2014
    • Frontpage
    • FSM
    • Guam
    • Hawaii
    • Insert Block
    • Kiribati
    • Marshall Is
    • Nauru
    • New Caledonia
    • Niue
    • Northern Marianas
    • NZ
    • Opinions
    • Pacific Headlines
    • Pacific Islands Forum
    • Pacific Press Releases
    • Palau
    • Papua New Guinea
    • RMI
    • Samoa
    • Solomon Is
    • Tahiti
    • Timor-Leste
    • Tokelau
    • Tonga
    • Tuvalu
    • Uncategorized
    • Vanuatu
    • West Papua

    Monthly Archives

    • April 2018
    • March 2018
    • February 2018
    • January 2018
    • December 2017
    • November 2017
    • October 2017
    • September 2017
    • August 2017
    • July 2017
    • June 2017
    • May 2017
    • April 2017
    • March 2017
    • February 2017
    • January 2017
    • December 2016
    • November 2016
    • October 2016
    • September 2016
    • August 2016
    • July 2016
    • June 2016
    • May 2016
    • April 2016
    • March 2016
    • February 2016
    • January 2016
    • December 2015
    • November 2015
    • October 2015
    • September 2015
    • August 2015
    • July 2015
    • June 2015
    • May 2015
    • April 2015
    • March 2015
    • February 2015
    • January 2015
    • December 2014
    • November 2014
    • October 2014
    • September 2014
    • August 2014
    • July 2014
    • June 2014
    • May 2014
    • April 2014
    • March 2014
    • February 2014
    • January 2014
    • December 2013
    • November 2013
    • October 2013
    • September 2013
    • August 2013
    • July 2013
    • June 2013
    • May 2013
    • April 2013
    • March 2013
    • February 2013
    • January 2013
    • December 2012
    • November 2012
    • October 2012
    • September 2012
    • August 2012
    • July 2012
    • June 2012
    • May 2012
    • April 2012
    • March 2012
    • February 2012
    • January 2012
    • December 2011
    • November 2011
    • October 2011
    • September 2011
    • August 2011
    • July 2011
    • June 2011
    • May 2011
    • April 2011
    • March 2011
    • February 2011
    • January 2011
    • December 2010
    • November 2010
    • October 2010
    • September 2010
    • August 2010
    • July 2010
    • June 2010
    • May 2010
    • April 2010
    • March 2010
    • February 2010
    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • September 2009
    • August 2009
    • July 2009
    • June 2009

    Recently on Scoop

    • Plunder Down Under: Rot in Australia’s Financial Services
    • Post Cabinet Press Conference 24/04/2018 – Veterans Funding
    • Commonwealth trade deal 'long way off' - Minister
    • 'We need culture change at the ministry' - PM
    • On why France could become our closest ally in Europe
    • Remembering the troops from our patch
    • North Korea: 'It's the next steps that are important' says P
    • Bankrolling the big prizes for NZ journalism
    • Tackling money-laundering in NZ: More needs to be done
    • Excitement over Commonwealth-wide free trade agreement

    Feeds

    • RSS Posts
    • RSS Comments
    Disclaimer
    All content is the work of the specific authors, journalists and researchers and not statements of opinion from AUT University.


    All editorial and news content is produced under the principles of Creative Commons. Permission to republish with attribution may be obtained from the Pacific Media Centre - pmc@aut.ac.nz

    Pacific.scoop.co.nz © 2018 | Powered by Scoop Media