Search
About Subscribe Advertise Submit News Media Tracking Feedback
Articles & Opinions Cook Is Fiji FSM Hawaii Kiribati Marshall Is Nauru New Caledonia Niue NZ
Papua New Guinea Samoa Solomon Is Tahiti Timor Leste Tokelau Tonga Tuvalu Vanuatu West Papua

Why ANZ tit-for-tat sanctions for Fiji suck

8:33 November 5, 2009Articles, Fiji 0 comments
Scott MacWilliam on a strategy rethink for Fiji. Photo: ANU

Scott MacWilliam on a strategy rethink for Fiji. Photo: ANU

Pacific.Scoop
Opinion – By Scott MacWilliam in Canberra

The latest development in ANZ-Fiji relations shows clearly why the model of sanctions being imposed on the South Pacific nation-state encourages tit-for-tat, ill-conceived moves by all parties.

While one view is that ANZ governments have been deliberately egging on the Fiji military government to become ever more extreme, this seems a less likely explanation than another possibility.

I favour the view that none of the three countries’ governments have much idea of how to resolve the current break-down in relations.

Australia and New Zealand are following an internationally favoured sanctions template, which has the virtue that it reduces the need for tactical thinking based on local knowledge. The Fiji military too, understands this template and is in a no stronger position to understand why the “super-powers” of the South Pacific seem only to be capable of punitive actions.

Sometimes flattered as representing “smart sanctions”, like all templates this one is rather rigid, a one-size-fits-all model which passes for a strategy and from which certain tactics automatically follow. It is an especially easy model to follow for politicians, diplomats and their advisers who have little local knowledge.

Avoid thinking
In particular, a prescribed set of sanctions makes it possible to avoid thinking whether these advance or retard the cause of bringing democracy to Fiji. Far easier to bar people in any way serving the Fiji government and administration from travelling to or through ANZ.

A clue to why it is vital to consider whether such sanctions are “smart” or “dumb” can be gauged from interim PM Voreqe Bainimarama’s response to the latest ANZ efforts. Advice from an Australian official to a Sri Lankan travelling to Fiji to take up a judicial appointment has led to a further major breach of diplomatic relations.

Fiji’s Prime Minister and Chief Justice Anthony Gates have both pointed out that this behaviour is a breach of Fiji’s sovereignty. The way both men have framed their objection provides the key to what is missing – a regard for nationalism, particularly among the educated elite, which is on the rise across the South Pacific.

Friends and associates from across the region regularly make the point: “We appreciate Australian aid, scholarships, study opportunities etc but we are Papua New Guineans/Solomon Islanders, ni-Vanuatu/Fijians first.”

An earlier generation of Australians and New Zealanders understood the power of the sentiment and often were the most vociferous anti-colonial nationalists. But this knowledge has been lost across the years.

‘This guy’
When the current Australian PM Kevin Rudd calls ex-Commodore Josaia Voreqe Bainimarama “this guy”, he is regarded as showing disrespect not only to the interim PM but also to the people of Fiji. Rudd should know this, had he any awareness of Fijian nationalism.

But he does not even though he regularly pulls on the trappings of Australian nationalism to justify his own behaviour.

Unfortunately it is not simply PM Rudd who has no understanding of the region. When an editor of one of the leading newspapers cannot tell Papua New Guineans Sir Michael Somare and Sir Rabbie Namaliu apart for a front page caption, then the lack of awareness clearly is deep in the Australian and New Zealand elite

This insensitivity, this lack of regard for the foremost representatives of South Pacific peoples, rankles across the region. It is not only Sir Michael Somare who has been deeply offended, and who in turn has retaliated on various occasions.

The current sanctions template encourages this insensitivity, makes it possible to avoid trying to understand what motivates people in power in each country. No need to think when steps 1, 2, 3 and so on are in the play book.

Failed model
The sanctions model also makes it possible for politicians and other officials in each country to take advice only from the people who agree with their “line”.

It is not only Fiji where dissident voices are given no serious consideration, even if in Australia and New Zealand they are occasionally allowed to ventilate concerns.

It is time for the Melanesian Spearhead Group, with people who represent both the first generation of anti-colonial nationalists and the new generation of post-colonial nationalists to find a way of showing what the Australian and New Zealand governments do not, and probably cannot, know.

As long as they are wedded to the sanctions model of non-diplomacy, certainly the “super-powers” will be do more harm than good.

Scott MacWilliam is an academic with the Australian National University’s College of Asia and the Pacific, and formerly of the University of the South Pacific and the University of Papua New Guinea.

  • Trackback-URL
  • Print This Post Print This Post
  • comments feed for this post

No comments yet.

Write a comment:

 

Search Pacific.scoop.co.nz






Text Links

  • Pacific Links

    • About Pacific.Scoop
    • AUT's new Pacific journalism course
    • Brown Pages
    • Knowledge Basket Pacific
    • Pacific Cooperation Foundation
    • Pacific Journalism Review
    • Pacific Media Centre – AUT University
    • Pacific Media Watch
    • Pasifika Foundation
    • University of the South Pacific
  • Pacific Media

    • Asia-Pacific (Al-Jazeera)
    • BBC’s Asia-Pacific
    • Cook Islands News
    • Fiji Daily Post
    • Fiji Sun
    • Fiji Times
    • Fijilive
    • Hawaiian Independent
    • Islands Business
    • La Dépêche de Tahiti
    • Les Nouvelles Calédoniennes
    • Matangi Tonga
    • Māori Television
    • New Dawn FM 95.3
    • NewsWire (Whitireia)
    • Niu FM
    • Oceania Flash
    • Pacific Islands Report
    • Pacific Mini Games newspaper
    • Pacnews
    • PIMA
    • PINA
    • PMC on YouTube
    • PNG Post-Courier
    • Radio Australia’s Pacific Beat
    • Radio Fiji
    • Radio NZ International
    • Radio Tarana
    • Radio Waatea
    • Reportage (UTS)
    • Reportage-Enviro
    • Samoa Observer
    • Samoalive Newsline
    • Solomon Star
    • Solomon Times
    • Sunday Chronicle (PNG)
    • Tagata Pasifika
    • Tahiti-Pacifique
    • Te Waha Nui (AUT)
    • The National (PNG)
    • TNews (NZ)
    • Vanuatu Daily Post
    • Xtra media
  • Pasifika Blogs

    • Avaiki Nius
    • Coup Four And A Half
    • Croz Walsh’s Fiji
    • David Robie’s Cafe Pacific
    • Global Voices Online
    • Malum Nalu’s PNG
    • Nga Reo Tangata
    • Pacific Eyewitness
    • Pacific Freedom Forum
    • Pacific Media Centre Niusblog
    • Tempo Semanal
    • Whenua Fenua Enua Vanua
  • BEHIND THE BALIBO FILM

    Director Robert Connolly and the actors talk about the dilemmas of recreating the covered-up Balibo journalist murders during the build-up to the Indonesian invasion of East Timor in 1975. See story. – Footprint Films

    REGION-WIDE NEWS:

      Pac Scoop Video3News: Key arrives without incident at Waitangi
      Pac Scoop Video3News: Valerie Vili triumphs again

    • Pacific Headlines

      • NZ scientists to gather data for Pacific disaster plan
      • PM Sikua supports Taiwan-funded MPs complex
      • Waiouru welcomes Timor-style Territorial Force soldier training
      • PM maps out 2010 policies in statement to Parliament
      • Due diligence would have kept Ashika in Fiji, says maritime expert
      • Pacific: UN meeting to review development goals
      • Pacific nations gather for UN development meeting in Vanuatu
      • Fiji Club praises ‘flying Fijians’
      • Human rights activist appointed East Timor’s first anti-corruption commissioner
      • Oxfam calls for rethink on global economic crisis in Pacific
      • Tonga College with brighter future thanks to Kiwi engineers
      • The Flipside of the Male Psyche – a marine saga
      • Pasifika Festival expands, features Mana Maoli
      • East Timor honours returning Aussie troops
      • Police commissioner thanks Hurricanes for help in Samoa campaign

    EAST TIMOR TARGETS GRAFT

    Timor-Leste President José Ramos Horta says corruption is rampant in the government ministries responsible for Customs, Procurement, Public Works and Rice Distribution. He promises to get tough on corruption in 2010. Interview: Bruce Honeywill, narrated by José Belo. See story. – Tempo Semanal



    MEET THE PMC TEAM

    Introducing some of the faces and projects involved in AUT's Pacific Media Centre. Meet Josephine Latu from Pacific Media Watch, Violet Cho from Irrawaddy magazine, filmmaker Jim Marbrook and TVNZ Tagata Pasifika's John Utanga, director David Robie and others. About Pacific Scoop. – PMC

    Text Links

    Toktok - Feedback

    • Charles Scheiner: This AFP article contains erro...
    • Karen Ross: The principle trainer of The T...
    • John Gibson: hey that's fantastic -great to...
    • John Pinkstone: Very sorry to hear of Prof Fut...
    • 44: 2Luks.....Lei Moce LoL!...
    • Alu: Dear Readers, Corruption is o...
    • Liu Muri: I disagree with you, Mark. NZ ...
    • mark: mutually beneficial??? how do ...
    • Colin: Just a few comments: This is t...
    • Sammy Josef: Wow! I just saw Noho Hewa last...

    Categories

    • American Samoa
    • Articles
    • Columns
    • Cook Is
    • Fiji
    • FSM
    • Guam
    • Hawaii
    • Kiribati
    • Marshall Is
    • Nauru
    • New Caledonia
    • Niue
    • NZ
    • Opinions
    • Pacific Headlines
    • Pacific Press Releases
    • Palau
    • Papua New Guinea
    • RMI
    • Samoa
    • Solomon Is
    • Tahiti
    • Timor-Leste
    • Tokelau
    • Tonga
    • Tuvalu
    • Uncategorized
    • Vanuatu
    • West Papua

    Monthly Archives

    • February 2010
    • January 2010
    • December 2009
    • November 2009
    • October 2009
    • September 2009
    • August 2009
    • July 2009
    • June 2009

    Recently on Scoop

    • ‘Terrifying’ Narcissism: J. D. Salinger’s Legacy
    • Top Scoop Stories February 9th 2010 News Summary
    • Scoop Full Coverage: Arts Festival 2010
    • KiwiFM: Manning Wallace Dig Deep Into Waitangi
    • Radio Adelaide: Selwyn Mannings NZ News Round-Up
    • Is One Iraqi’s Self-Hatred Newsworthy?
    • Plains FM Audio: Mornings – Jantina Huls
    • Scoop Top 30 Daily Ratings 08 February 2010
    • Uri Avnery: A Four-Letter Word
    • PMs Presser – No Taxation Without Presentation

    Feeds

    • RSS Posts
    • RSS Comments
    Disclaimer
    All content is the work of the specific authors, journalists and researchers and not statements of opinion from AUT University.


    All editorial and news content is produced under the principles of Creative Commons. Permission to republish with attribution may be obtained from the Pacific Media Centre - pmc@aut.ac.nz

    Pacific.scoop.co.nz © 2010 | Powered by Scoop Media